metal talk
facebook
Type band name, album name, artists name etc here...
Search all our articles by typing band name, album name, artists name etc here...
news now
metal talk

  JONATHAN CHURCHILL: DEFENDING OUR ISLAND

LOU REED & METALLICA
'Lulu'
(Warner Bros)
Released: 31st October 2011


jonathan churchill



You know the dread that comes over you when a friend offers to show you all their wedding photos? And the video too? Well that's the feeling you ought to get if somebody offers to play you a track from Lou Reed and Metallica's collaboration, 'Lulu'. I've had the opportunity to listen to the entire album. All of it. Every note. It's fair to say that it has left a lasting impression.

metallicaloureedlulu

MetalTalk.net is all about positivity. We love our Metal and we're certainly not here to knock rock stars with fragile egos and too much money off their perches. Something, however, has gone horribly wrong and it's only fair that we should hold a Metal inquisition.

The first thing to establish is exactly what on earth this is. Well, according to the official press release, 'Lulu' is a set of extended songs inspired by German expressionist Frank Wedekind's early 20th Century plays, 'Earth Spirit' and 'Pandora's Box' (much admired by Freud). The plays, originally published in 1904 and set in Germany, Paris and London in the 1890s, whirl between the points of view of Lulu, an inverted-Eve-like cipher-mirror of desire and abuse, and the people who fall desperately in love with her. Then she meets Jack The Ripper...

Article continues below...


iron maiden


Reed had previously sketched out some lyrics and after meeting with Metallica in 2009, they decided to work together. At first glance, a genuinely innovative and exciting idea. The power and intensity of Metallica in full flow, but with a lyricist and poet who can write words that infiltrate your soul.

As a fully inducted member of the Rock 'n' Roll Hall of Fame, Lou Reed has earned a great deal of respect throughout his career. His dark, obscure and nihilistic outpourings are perfect for heavy Metal and there's a genuine resonance between the music and lyrics on Lulu. It's unfortunate then that, as far as I can tell, it's pure self-indulgent nonsense.

What we have here is a mixed bag of pretentious lyrics and tedious music which surprises and delights in equal measure. Surprises because it's much more boring and faux-intellectual than I could have imagined. And delights because it is hilarious to think that thousands of unsuspecting rednecks in the Deep South may be getting this for Christmas alongside their new baseball cap and Kid Rock's Greatest Hits.

In my opinion, Metallica have struggled for years now to lay the ghost of 'The Black Album' to rest. Regardless of your opinion on thatrecord, it is a monster and it's not that they aren't talented enough to move forward, but I've always felt they lost their sense of purpose. As a fervently anti-establishment band in the early eighties, 'The Black Album' introduced them to the mainstream. It simultaneously launched them into the stratosphere and ruined their Metal credentials. Millions of people who would never touch a Slayer or Megadeth album suddenly embraced Metallica, who just recently performed at a corporate event for Salesforce.com. That's the sort of behaviour you expect from KISS, not a proper thrash Metal band.

Lou Reed, on the other hand, clearly needs an outlet for his poetry. The bin would be my suggestion. However, Metallica have decided to put it to music. Fair enough. They probably weren't sure how to politely say "no", and the next thing you know they're all in a recording studio, and one thing led to another. I'm presuming Trent Reznor had a similar issues when Rob Halford popped in one day wearing a feather boa and eyeliner, clutching some surreal lyrics, asking to make an industrial album with his new band, 2wo.

What interests me is that the album is very true to itself and is totally non-commercial. It means that if this sells or is critically acclaimed, it will be on the strength of the material and not because there are two famous names involved. The cover artwork is provocative and blatantly sets the tone for what's inside. And the overall lyrical content and musical feel is basically the mad Danish director, Lars von Trier, set to music. So far so Lou Reed then.

Getting under the skin of 'Lulu' requires patience, stamina and a very open mind. It's a record that will polarise opinion for years to come, but I'm sure - just like Meatloaf's 'Bat Out Of Hell III' - there is somebody, somewhere, alone and in a black T-shirt, who will genuinely appreciate this record.

Notable moments include:

'The View', an interesting slow-paced track with a gentle drum intro and an introspective poetry-style spoken word delivery. There's a real sense of Michael Stipe's vocal from REM's 'New Adventures In Hi-Fi', another deliberately non-commercial piece. This track reminds me strongly of 'E-bow The Letter'. It's just nowhere near as good.

'Frustration' focuses just on the drums and vocals for large parts. It's interesting to hear Lars freestyling with Reed droning over the top. It's certainly different and definitely doesn't sound like it was written by an eight year-old with ADHD.

According to press interviews with the band, 'Junior Dad', the nineteen-minute finale, brought James and Kirk to tears. The last eight minutes or so is just the sound of what may be a viola gently playing one note. It will reduce most Metallica fans to tears.

anthraxworshipmusic

Conclusion:

Reviewing a collaboration is a tricky business. Is this a Metallica album featuring Lou Reed or a Lou Reed album featuring Metallica? The difference is important. Lou Reed being a seminal sixties and seventies artistic pioneer. Metallica being the world's most popular heavy Metal band. They have widely different audiences and little crossover.

A new Lou Reed album is to be treated with extreme caution. It's bound to be 'artistic' and 'challenging' and have an alleged intellectual depth. Invariably, it won't be popular.

These days though, a new Metallica album is, in fact, also to be treated with caution! Recent releases have been - um - 'artistic', 'challenging' and have had an alleged new-found intellectual depth. Invariably, they aren't popular.

Having put 'Lulu' through a Metal Inquisition and tightened the thumbscrews on this bizarre experiment, it's fair to say that I think this is very much a Lou Reed record. Metallica have done a fair job of creating an audio landscape for his poetic gushing, but the lyrics and delivery by Reed is so dominant that it's easy to overlook Metallica's contribution. As such, if you're a fan of Lou Reed, this is another great challenging artistic piece with hidden depths. I'm sure it will win a Grammy or find favour with pseudo-intellectuals who enjoy alternative sounds.

If you're Metallica fan, I'd suggest you don't put yourself through the torment of this record. There's little here for thrash fans and it's best viewed as an experiment and not a proper Metallica record. For those brave enough to take the 'Lulu' challenge - please post your comments below or on the MetalTalk.net Facebook page! For me - it's a thumbs down. It's not an album I'd ever listen to under any circumstances, but credit to Metallica for trying something new. However, Anthrax and Megadeth have both been busy in the studio proving that their 1980s success was no fluke. Megadeth's previous two albums have been outstanding and Anthrax's 'Worship Music' is easily one of the albums of the year. The question must be asked why on earth Metallica aren't able to find a similar vein of form? They certainly seem to have time on their hands to showcase their talents with Lou Reed.

Listen to whole album:

http://www.loureedmetallica.com/listen-to-lulu.php


26.10.11

Jonathan Churchill. MetalTalk.net
Follow me on Twitter: MetalTalk_1976


Share |




iron maiden



 

hrh nwobhm RAVEN AND DIAMOND HEAD TO PLAY HRH NWOBHM 2017 - FULL LINE-UP IS HERE
"HRH are proud to announce that HRH NWOBHM will make its thunderous, triumphant return in 2017..."

gojira GOJIRA MARCH 2017 HEADLINE TOUR DATES ARE HERE
The band's latest album, 'Magma', is already notching up number one positions in the 2016 end of year Top Album polls...

xandria WORLD PREMIERE: XANDRIA UNLEASH FIRST TRACK FROM FORTHCOMING NEW ALBUM ON MetalTalk
The band around charismatic Dianne van Giersbergen unleashes the very first music video from 'Theater Of Dimensions'...

blaze bayley WORLD PREMIERE: BLAZE BAYLEY RELEASES BRAND NEW CHRISTMAS SONG AND VIDEO, 'CRAZY CHRISTMAS'
Blaze Bayley has released a brand new Christmas song and the video is premiering here on MetalTalk today...

marillion WAS BREAKING NEWS: ZZ TOP TO HEADLINE RAMBLIN' MAN 2017
"Without a further a do here are the first acts we can proudly announce for Ramblin' Man Fair 2017!!"

marillion WAS BREAKING NEWS: DEEP PURPLE 2017 UK TOUR DATES ARE HERE
Tickets have started to go on sale already right here.

matt starr ACE FREHLEY AND MR BIG DRUMMER MATT STARR RELEASES 'MUST-SEE' DVD
"Educating and empowering other musicians around the world is something very important to us both..."

hereza STATUS QUO CONFIRM LAST OF THE ELECTRICS TOUR WILL CONTINUE INTO 2017
"The tour will run alongside a series of Aquostic shows already planned for 2017..."

hereza UK PREMIERE: HEREZA LAUNCH SECOND MUSIC VIDEO FROM 'I BECOME DEATH'
Croatian death-punk duo HerezA are making waves around Europe and when you see this, you'll know exactly why...

status quo UK EXCLUSIVE: STATUS QUO KEEP ROCKIN' ON: DATES WITH ZZ TOP PLUS 2018 GIG ANNOUNCED
According to RP Online, tickets will be available from Thursday 1st December at 10:00am...

ted nugent TED NUGENT CELEBRATES FIDEL CASTRO'S DEATH
"I'm giddy the son of a bitch is dead. It's time to celebrate..."

unleash the archers WORLD PREMIERE: UNLEASH THE ARCHERS UNVEIL THIRD AND FINAL VIDEO FROM 'TIME STANDS STILL'
"We are so excited to finally share this video with everyone! It's our thank you to all the fans we've met and made on our first European tour..."

marillion WAS BREAKING NEWS: MARILLION TO PLAY THEIR FIRST EVER SHOW AT ROYAL ALBERT HALL
"Conscious of the venue's history and having seen one or two first-rate shows there myself, we will make a show worthy of this hallowed space."

deep purple DEEP PURPLE TO HEADLINE HELLFEST - FULL BILL IS HERE
Just as they did last year, Hellfest have announced the full bill in one hit and the 2017 line-up is varied and incredibly strong...

kiss WAS BREAKING NEWS: KISS 2017 UK TOUR DATES ARE HERE
We love Kiss because when their fans shout, they listen and take action...

stone sour STONE SOUR TENTH ANNIVERSARY EDITION OF 'COME WHAT(EVER) MAY' IS COMING: NEW VIDEO FOR 'ZZYZX RD' ACOUSTIC IS HERE
'Come What(ever) May: Deluxe 10th Anniversary Edition' has been remastered and now includes an array of bonus material...

nightlord WORLD PREMIERE: NIGHTLORD RELEASE VIDEO FOR 'SIN EATER' - WATCH IT HERE
This is a pulsating and gripping track and you can see it for the very first time right here...

kiss WAS BREAKING NEWS: KISS 2017 EUROPEAN TOUR DATES ARE HERE
This will be the first time the band have hit Europe since 2015s sold out festival and arena shows...

deep purple DEEP PURPLE TO RELEASE NEW STUDIO ALBUM, 'INFINITE', IN 2017
"This is primarily an instrumental band. I just climb on board and write it along."

manowar MANOWAR ADD EXTRA GERMAN DATE TO THE FINAL BATTLE WORLD TOUR
"Our German Army Of Immortals is faithfully devoted and strong in numbers. We had to give them an additional show to saturate their thirst for True Metal!"

queen QUEEN + ADAM LAMBERT TO RELEASE 'LIVE IN JAPAN'
"When we saw the video, we thought that it was great and the interaction with the crowd was great."

def leppard DEF LEPPARD TELL FANS 'AND THERE WILL BE A NEXT TIME - LIVE FROM DETROIT'
"From the second the house lights went down, we could see the sun setting from the stage, and the energy from the crowd just seemed to intensify..."

donald trump MUNICIPAL WASTE ACCUSE DONALD TRUMP OF HACKING THEIR TWITTER ACCOUNT
Surprisingly the band are not deleting these posts and they are still there for all to see...

ghost GHOST UK AND EUROPE TOUR DATES ARE HERE
These dates mark the band's return to UK shores following their extremely special seated show last March...

absolva ABSOLVA CONFIRM RETURN TO THE STUDIO AND 2017 PLANS
"We see the new record as a mix of what we did with 'Anthems To The Dead' and 'Never A Good Day To Die'..."

marco mendoza MARCO MENDOZA TO RETURN TO THE UK IN FEBRUARY
Some new material will be offered up on the tour along with some of the greatest hits Marco has played...

saiichi sugiyami SAIICHI SUGIYAMI TO PLAY TWELVE DATE SPRING 2017 UK TOUR
'Melting Away' was one of Andy Fraser's last ever recordings and you can check it out right here...

accept ACCEPT RELEASE FIRST TRAILER FOR 'RESTLESS AND WILD LIVE' - WATCH HERE
'Restless And Live', will include the entire show Accept played at Bang Your Head Festival 2015...

paul shortino EXCLUSIVE: PAUL SHORTINO GIVES STELLAR CAREER PERSPECTIVE TO BE AIRED THIS MONDAY
Being introduced to Ronnie James Dio was a total life changer: "I felt like I was living in a dream."

billy sheehan BILLY SHEEHAN ISSUES DAVE LEE ROTH DENIAL
"I shared the post because it was about Sammy getting back in VH. I have since deleted it..."

saxon WAS BREAKING NEWS: SAXON TO HEADLINE STEELHOUSE WITH EXCLUSIVE 'EAGLE' PRODUCTION: INGLORIOUS ALSO ON THE BILL
"We're bringing the Eagle back to the mountain, so bring on the Heavy Metal thunder."

glenn hughes WAS BREAKING NEWS: GLENN HUGHES NEW UK/EUROPEAN TOUR DATES ARE HERE
"I am happy to announce my UK and European tour. My team have been hard at work to make this happen..."

nightlord NEW NIGHTLORD ALBUM IS ON THE WAY - DETAILS HERE
'Reborn In Darkness' features the first new Nightlord tracks since the band reformed in 2010...

van hagar WAS BREAKING NEWS: VAN HAGAR AND DAVE LEE ROTH'S EAT 'EM AND SMILE LINE-UPS TO REFORM
The members have refused to deny such a thing is happening. Instead Billy Sheehan cheekily re-tweeted the RothArmy article...

magnum WAS BREAKING NEWS: MAGNUM TO RELEASE 'THE VALLEY OF TEARS – THE BALLADS' ALBUM ON 6th JANUARY
"Magnum have so many beautiful quiet numbers, why don't you put together a compilation highlighting some of the most powerful tracks?"

elo JEFF LYNNE'S ELO ARE STEPPING OUT FOR SHEFFIELD ARENA SHOW
Presale for the Sheffield show starts on Wednesday and go on sale proper this Friday...

the king lot THE KING LOT/THE JOLLY BOYS AIM FOR CHRISTMAS NUMBER ONE WITH TYKETTTO COVER FOR MS SCOTLAND
"As The MS Society is The Jolly Boys chosen charity for 2016, we wanted to do something that would raise the most money and awareness..."

sertraline SERTRALINE ARE TRYING TO MAKE YOU FEEL GUILTY WITH SECOND EP
"This has been a long time coming! We're so grateful for everyone's support, thanks for sticking with us!"

deep purple DEEP PURPLE 'CALIFORNIA JAM 1974' AND JON LORD 'GEMINI SUITE' NEWLY RESTORED AND ON THEIR WAY TO YOU
"It's big, it's grandiose, it's funky, it's rock... it's Mk III in all its glory."

quireboys THE QUIREBOYS ARE COMING - FULLY PLUGGED AND FULLY LOADED
"We made this record with a full-on rock'n'roll show in mind..."

accept ACCEPT REVEAL 'RESTLESS AND WILD' FROM 'RESTLESS AND LIVE' - WATCH HERE
This package will include the entire show Accept played at Bang Your Head Festival 2015...

overkill OVERKILL TO RELEASE NEW ALBUM, 'THE GRINDING WHEEL', IN FEBRUARY
"Grinding on! Here we come again kids, strapped to the Grinding Wheel! Bang your head."

guns n roses GUNS N' ROSES SLOT FEATURES IN TOP ROCK THEMED GAMES
Gunners fans can now listen to their favourite band's music and win big prizes on the reels...

hard rock hell AIRBOURNE, Y&T, GUN, SYTERIA AND THE NEW ROSES TO ROCK HARD ROCK HELL 2017
2017 is going to be the biggest adventure yet! We're taking the HRH experience out to Australia, NZ and Singapore...

helloween KISKE AND HANSEN BACK IN HELLOWEEN: PUMPKINS UNITED WORLD TOUR 2017/18 IS OFFICIAL
Weikath, Kiske, Hansen, Grosskopf are going to play Helloween classics live and on a joint tour. Massive news. Awesome...

motorhead MOTÖRHEAD 'WAKE THE DEAD' BOX-SET AND 'BAD MAGIC' SILVER VINYL AVAILABLE TO ORDER NOW
The main cover image highlights one of Lemmy's rough-draft thumbnail sketches...

anthrax ANTHRAX ANNOUNCE 2017 UK HEADLINE TOUR
"Finally! We've been looking forward to headlining in the UK for so long!!! We have a killer set planned..."

devildriver DEVILDRIVER PREMIERE NEW VIDEO FOR 'TRUST NO ONE'
"The pit was giant for us and it was killer to see such a massive crowd participating in the madness!"

tyketto TYKETTO REACH OUT TO FANS ONCE AGAIN WITH RESCHEDLUED TOUR DATES
"Save a handful of venues, we will be hitting most of the same markets as we had planned for in November and December..."

aerosmith AEROSMITH 'AERO-VEDERCI BABY' FAREWELL TOUR DATES ARE HERE
"Aerosmith just got done ripping through South America like true ambassadors of rock... the band is unstoppable right now..."

death dealer HAS DONALD TRUMP ASSASSINATED DEATH DEALER?
"Shut the fuck up and play guitar, that's what matters, not your opinion..."

diablus in musica WORLD PREMIERE: DIABALUS IN MUSICA UNLEASH 'INVISIBLE' FROM 'DIRGE FROM THE ARCHONS'
Diabulus In Musica have an extraordinary ability to merge Metallic heaviness with symphonic catchiness...

kiss KISSCLUSIVE: KISS KRUISE VI - QUALITY VIDEO OF EXCLUSIVE SONGS INCLUDING A PREVIOUSLY UNHEARD PAUL STANLEY TRACK
"We are proud to be part of such a great, noble and worthy cause. Please support the Heavy Metal Helps The Heroes Campaign."

inglorious LIMITED EDITION EXCLUSIVE INGLORIOUS 2016 COMMEMORATION T-SHIRT LAUNCHED
We're doing just one run of these to ensure that all Inglorious fans who purchase one have a limited edition exclusive collector's item...

roger waters ROGER WATERS ANNOUNCES 2017 NORTH AMERICAN TOUR DATES
"It will be a cool show, I promise you. It'll be spectacular like all my shows have been."

tom petty JEFF LYNNE, DON HENLEY AND FOO FIGHTERS HAVE NO SECOND THOUGHTS PERFORMING AT TOM PETTY MUSICARES AWARD
"I have so much respect for this organization, which really does care about the people in our industry..."

rhino edwards FOR STATUS QUO FANS: RHINO'S REVENGE ANNOUNCE NEW NEW NEW BATCH OF TOUR DATES
The tour is in support of the 'II' album which was released late last year...

grand magus WAS BREAKING NEWS: GRAND MAGUS ANNOUNCE UK/IRELAND TOUR DATES
"By Odin's beard! The Magus will be returning to the British isles for a headline tour with all that it entails in 2017..."

wildfire festival WILDFIRE FESTIVAL ANNOUNCES TWENTY BANDS FOR 2017
"For anyone that wants to discover and back new bands there is one place to be next June – Wildfire Festival..."

kiss KISSCLUSIVE: KISS REVIVE CLASSIC 'CREATURES OF THE NIGHT' SET ON KRUISE VI
The setlist was based around the 1982 'Creatures Of The Night' tour list but with some amazing surprises thrown in...

trivium TRIVIUM UNEARTH RARE DEMO AHEAD OF RE-RELEASE - LISTEN HERE
'The Storm' is a Trivium track of legend. It's been completely absent from the world for ages since it was only very briefly available on 'Caeruleus'...

bullet for my valentine BULLET FOR MY VALENTINE RELEASE BRAND NEW SINGLE/VIDEO, 'DON'T NEED YOU' - WATCH/LISTEN HERE
"We wanted it to look really grand and ornate, but underneath it all, it's a bit dirty."

bristol deathfest VADER AND IMMOLATION CONFIRMED FOR BRISTOL DEATHFEST
Bristol Deathfest is one of the must attend events for any fan of death Metal in the UK next year...

steelhouse festival STEELHOUSE FESTIVAL ANNOUNCES 2017 SATURDAY HEADLINERS
"After the success of last year's event we are delighted to be pulling the kind of acts that will really maintain our upward trajectory!"

amon amarth AMON AMARTH TO HEADLINE BLOODSTOCK FRIDAY - TICKETS ON SALE NOW
Amon Amarth will headline the Friday night of Bloodstock 2017 in what is certain to be a very serious horn raising spectacular...

killit WORLD PREMIERE KILLIT UNVEIL 'AIN'T PLAYING YOUR GAME' VIDEO, LIVE AT THE UNDERWORLD
"There is no way to get any video to actually make people realise how it felt that night in The Underworld... but this is as close as it gets."

mick ralphs BAD COMPANY AND MOTT THE HOOPLE GUITARIST MICK RALPHS SUFFERS STROKE
"Mick is receiving excellent medical care and is recovering in hospital, although all his public engagements are necessarily on hold..."

meat loaf EXCLUSIVE ANDREW POLEC, 'BAT OUT OF HELL - THE MUSICAL' LEADING MAN: "EVERYTHING HAS LED TO THIS MOMENT"
"Considering there's a huge bike accident in this play and my life karmically changed because of my bike accident, I feel blessed."

tank WORLD PREMIERE TANK UNLEASH SUPERB NEW VIDEO FOR 'VALLEY OF TEARS'
"Not exactly ideal conditions when you've got a stinking hangover. Nothing we couldn't deal with though. Job done!"

ded daisies THE DEAD DAISIES UNLEASH SHORT MOVIE FOR 'A SONG AND A PRAYER'
"This song turned out to have a special vibe to it, very accessible, which is really cool. But the lyrics are rather dark..."

download DOWNLOAD 2017 HEADLINERS ANNOUNCED
Download mainman Andy Copping has established for himself a new status as the bravest promoter in the business...

deep purple DEEP PURPLE 'FOR ONE NIGHT ONLY' PERFECTLY CAPTURES KNEBWORTH 1985 PERFORMANCE
This hardback 128 page book is a strictly limited edition of 300 with each one individually numbered...

beermageddon BEERMAGEDDON MAKE FIRST 2017 BAND ANNOUNCEMENTS
It's game on for Beermageddon and there's a whole host of fabulous acts playing the 2017 edition of the booziest festival in the UK...

rush RUSH TO RELEASE 'TIME STAND STILL' DOCUMENTARY
Dave Grohl: "Rush built their following the right way. Their legacy is incredible and their influence undeniable."

titanfest EXCLUSIVE FAST EDDIE CLARKE JOINS SAXON ONSTAGE FOR MOTÖRHEAD CLASSIC
Biff: "It's great to see Eddie playing again..."

glenn hughes GLENN HUGHES CANCELS ENTIRE UK/EUROPEAN TOUR
"I am saddened and disappointed that I will not be able to perform for my UK and European fans as I had originally intended..."

metal talk
© All written site content is copyright MetalTalk.net 2008-2016, unless otherwise stated, and is not to be used without prior permission.
Ads raid data recovery