metal talk
metal talk
  JONATHAN CHURCHILL: DEFENDING OUR ISLAND

LOU REED & METALLICA
'Lulu'
(Warner Bros)
Released: 31st October 2011


jonathan churchill



You know the dread that comes over you when a friend offers to show you all their wedding photos? And the video too? Well that's the feeling you ought to get if somebody offers to play you a track from Lou Reed and Metallica's collaboration, 'Lulu'. I've had the opportunity to listen to the entire album. All of it. Every note. It's fair to say that it has left a lasting impression.

metallicaloureedlulu

MetalTalk.net is all about positivity. We love our Metal and we're certainly not here to knock rock stars with fragile egos and too much money off their perches. Something, however, has gone horribly wrong and it's only fair that we should hold a Metal inquisition.

The first thing to establish is exactly what on earth this is. Well, according to the official press release, 'Lulu' is a set of extended songs inspired by German expressionist Frank Wedekind's early 20th Century plays, 'Earth Spirit' and 'Pandora's Box' (much admired by Freud). The plays, originally published in 1904 and set in Germany, Paris and London in the 1890s, whirl between the points of view of Lulu, an inverted-Eve-like cipher-mirror of desire and abuse, and the people who fall desperately in love with her. Then she meets Jack The Ripper...

Article continues below...

iron maiden



Reed had previously sketched out some lyrics and after meeting with Metallica in 2009, they decided to work together. At first glance, a genuinely innovative and exciting idea. The power and intensity of Metallica in full flow, but with a lyricist and poet who can write words that infiltrate your soul.

As a fully inducted member of the Rock 'n' Roll Hall of Fame, Lou Reed has earned a great deal of respect throughout his career. His dark, obscure and nihilistic outpourings are perfect for heavy Metal and there's a genuine resonance between the music and lyrics on Lulu. It's unfortunate then that, as far as I can tell, it's pure self-indulgent nonsense.

What we have here is a mixed bag of pretentious lyrics and tedious music which surprises and delights in equal measure. Surprises because it's much more boring and faux-intellectual than I could have imagined. And delights because it is hilarious to think that thousands of unsuspecting rednecks in the Deep South may be getting this for Christmas alongside their new baseball cap and Kid Rock's Greatest Hits.

In my opinion, Metallica have struggled for years now to lay the ghost of 'The Black Album' to rest. Regardless of your opinion on thatrecord, it is a monster and it's not that they aren't talented enough to move forward, but I've always felt they lost their sense of purpose. As a fervently anti-establishment band in the early eighties, 'The Black Album' introduced them to the mainstream. It simultaneously launched them into the stratosphere and ruined their Metal credentials. Millions of people who would never touch a Slayer or Megadeth album suddenly embraced Metallica, who just recently performed at a corporate event for Salesforce.com. That's the sort of behaviour you expect from KISS, not a proper thrash Metal band.

Lou Reed, on the other hand, clearly needs an outlet for his poetry. The bin would be my suggestion. However, Metallica have decided to put it to music. Fair enough. They probably weren't sure how to politely say "no", and the next thing you know they're all in a recording studio, and one thing led to another. I'm presuming Trent Reznor had a similar issues when Rob Halford popped in one day wearing a feather boa and eyeliner, clutching some surreal lyrics, asking to make an industrial album with his new band, 2wo.

What interests me is that the album is very true to itself and is totally non-commercial. It means that if this sells or is critically acclaimed, it will be on the strength of the material and not because there are two famous names involved. The cover artwork is provocative and blatantly sets the tone for what's inside. And the overall lyrical content and musical feel is basically the mad Danish director, Lars von Trier, set to music. So far so Lou Reed then.

Getting under the skin of 'Lulu' requires patience, stamina and a very open mind. It's a record that will polarise opinion for years to come, but I'm sure - just like Meatloaf's 'Bat Out Of Hell III' - there is somebody, somewhere, alone and in a black T-shirt, who will genuinely appreciate this record.

Notable moments include:

'The View', an interesting slow-paced track with a gentle drum intro and an introspective poetry-style spoken word delivery. There's a real sense of Michael Stipe's vocal from REM's 'New Adventures In Hi-Fi', another deliberately non-commercial piece. This track reminds me strongly of 'E-bow The Letter'. It's just nowhere near as good.

'Frustration' focuses just on the drums and vocals for large parts. It's interesting to hear Lars freestyling with Reed droning over the top. It's certainly different and definitely doesn't sound like it was written by an eight year-old with ADHD.

According to press interviews with the band, 'Junior Dad', the nineteen-minute finale, brought James and Kirk to tears. The last eight minutes or so is just the sound of what may be a viola gently playing one note. It will reduce most Metallica fans to tears.

anthraxworshipmusic

Conclusion:

Reviewing a collaboration is a tricky business. Is this a Metallica album featuring Lou Reed or a Lou Reed album featuring Metallica? The difference is important. Lou Reed being a seminal sixties and seventies artistic pioneer. Metallica being the world's most popular heavy Metal band. They have widely different audiences and little crossover.

A new Lou Reed album is to be treated with extreme caution. It's bound to be 'artistic' and 'challenging' and have an alleged intellectual depth. Invariably, it won't be popular.

These days though, a new Metallica album is, in fact, also to be treated with caution! Recent releases have been - um - 'artistic', 'challenging' and have had an alleged new-found intellectual depth. Invariably, they aren't popular.

Having put 'Lulu' through a Metal Inquisition and tightened the thumbscrews on this bizarre experiment, it's fair to say that I think this is very much a Lou Reed record. Metallica have done a fair job of creating an audio landscape for his poetic gushing, but the lyrics and delivery by Reed is so dominant that it's easy to overlook Metallica's contribution. As such, if you're a fan of Lou Reed, this is another great challenging artistic piece with hidden depths. I'm sure it will win a Grammy or find favour with pseudo-intellectuals who enjoy alternative sounds.

If you're Metallica fan, I'd suggest you don't put yourself through the torment of this record. There's little here for thrash fans and it's best viewed as an experiment and not a proper Metallica record. For those brave enough to take the 'Lulu' challenge - please post your comments below or on the MetalTalk.net Facebook page! For me - it's a thumbs down. It's not an album I'd ever listen to under any circumstances, but credit to Metallica for trying something new. However, Anthrax and Megadeth have both been busy in the studio proving that their 1980s success was no fluke. Megadeth's previous two albums have been outstanding and Anthrax's 'Worship Music' is easily one of the albums of the year. The question must be asked why on earth Metallica aren't able to find a similar vein of form? They certainly seem to have time on their hands to showcase their talents with Lou Reed.

Listen to whole album:

http://www.loureedmetallica.com/listen-to-lulu.php


26.10.11

Jonathan Churchill. MetalTalk.net
Follow me on Twitter: MetalTalk_1976


Share |




iron maiden



 

queen 'QUEEN ON AIR' WILL TAKE YOUR BREATH AWAY: RELEASE DATE AND CONTENTS RIGHT HERE
There's over three-and-a-half hours of revealing encounters recorded for the BBC and Capital Radio in London between 1976-1992...

iron maiden IRON MAIDEN ADD NEW DATE TO BOOK OF SOULS UK/EUROPEAN TOUR
"To add a second show at the London O2 arena at such an early stage demonstrates just how strong Iron Maiden are in the UK..."

grace digger PREPARE TO BE HEALED BY METAL: GRAVE DIGGER TO DELIVER TEN COMMANDMENTS ON FRIDAY 13th
"Grave Digger are back with a brand new album, and we're stronger, heavier and more Metal than ever!"

marcela bovio MARCELA BOVIO ANNOUNCES SOLO EUROPEAN TOUR DATES IN SUPPORT OF 'UNPRECEDENTED'
"This will be the first extended run of shows where fans can get to hear her new classically influenced material in headline shows..."

behemoth BEHEMOTH TO HEADLINE HEAVY SCOTLAND WITH ARCH ENEMY
Aiming to be the biggest and best new festival dedicated to all things dark, heavy, and vicious, Heavy Scotland is borne out of a love of Metal...

motley crue MÖTLEY CRÜE: RELEASE DATE FOR 'THE END – LIVE IN LOS ANGELES' IS HERE
Fans were left in tears as the show concluded with an emotional encore rendition of 'Home Sweet Home' from the second stage riser...

slayer SLAYER TO RELEASE 30th ANNIVERSARY 'REIGN IN BLOOD' PLAQUES
'Reign In Blood' was originally released on 7th October 1986 via Def Jam Recordings and was the band's first collaboration with Rick Rubin...

rainbow RITCHIE BLACKMORE'S RAINBOW TO RELEASE 'MEMORIES IN ROCK - LIVE IN GERMANY' IN NOVEMBER
This film captures the long awaited return to rock music for former the Deep Purple guitarist...

iced earth JAKE DREYER IS THE NEW ICED EARTH GUITARIST
"Jake will play on the upcoming Iced Earth studio album and will perform his first live show with us in November at Hammerfest in Germany..."

quartz QUARTZ ORIGINAL VOCALIST MIKE 'TAFFY' TAYLOR PASSES AWAY
"Our thoughts and deepest sympathies and condolences go out to his family and to all who were lucky enough to have met and known him. Legend."

metallica WAS BREAKING NEWS: NEW METALLICA VIDEO FOR 'MOTH INTO FLAME' IS HERE
Metallica's brand new official video for 'Moth Into Flame' from their forthcoming new album, 'Hardwired... To Self-Destruct' has just dropped...

jack bruce AN EVENING FOR JACK BRUCE GUESTS ANNOUNCED
'Very special guests' are still to be announced and we're speculating on whether or not Eric Clapton may be one of them...

titanfest TITANFEST CONFIRMS FINAL LINE-UP FOR 2016
"Hell is honoured to be included in the stellar line-up for this year's Titanfest and we look forward to laying waste to London...

freddie mercury ACM'S FREDDIE MERCURY SCHOLARSHIP WINNER ANNOUNCED
"Freddie wrote and recorded so much material at our studio and we really feel his legacy lives on whenever we hear his Fazioli grand piano..."

cat stevens METALLICA HARDWIRE CENTRAL PARK WITH CAT STEVENS
"Because this world is big enough to share and for it to go round..."

la guns WAS BREAKING NEWS: LA GUNS, WITH TRACII AND PHIL, UK TOUR DATES ARE HERE
"The only time we really bitch at each other is when we're in a band together, or when we're not in a band together..."

geoff tate WAS BREAKING NEWS: GEOFF TATE IS GONNA GET CLOSE TO YOU ON UK/EUROPEAN ACOUSTIC TOUR
The tour across Europe will see Geoff performing a very special night of story telling and acoustic songs spanning his thirty-five year career...

dan reed WAS BREAKING NEWS: DAN REED NETWORK ANNOUNCE 2017 UK TOUR
"After twenty-five years we were able to gravitate back to the passion we discovered playing together all those years ago, and battle once more!"

paco ventura UK EXCLUSIVE: KISS, EUROPE, RAINBOW STARS AND MORE FEATURE ON 'PACO VENTURA BLACK MOON'. LISTEN HERE
It's a powerful album with songs in English and Spanish and will appeal to lovers of Whitesnake, Rainbow and Yngwie Malmsteen...

berserker LITHUANIAN VIKINGS BERSERKER TO UNDERTAKE FIRST UK TOUR
This band deserves support so get your drinking horns out and go enjoy. You'll be glad you did...

hrh metal HRH METAL IS HERE: TWENTY QUID TO SEE SODOM, RAGING SPEEDHORN, EVILE, LAWNMOWER DETH AND MANY MORE
"It's the tenth year of HRH and it's time we gave all fans old and new something to celebrate it with..."

as i lay dying AS I LAY DYING SINGER TIM LAMBESIS FILES $35MILLION LAWSUIT OVER STEROID MAN-BOOBS
"The terror I felt at this moment of confirmed maturation has left me traumatized indefinitely..."

lynyrd skynyrd LYNYRD SKYNYRD FANS TAKE IT ON FAITH WITH NEW GARY ROSSINGTON ALBUM
"Even some of the Skynyrd band would say to us 'Hey, go do something — the fans want to hear it', so we finally we thought, 'Well, let's just do it.'"

stone hroken STONE BROKEN WILL WAIT FOR YOU WITH NEW SINGLE
The fourth single to be taken from their acclaimed debut album, 'All The Time', this is sure to be THE power ballad for 2016...

the who THE WHO TO PERFORM 'TOMMY' ACOUSTIC AT THE ROYAL ALBERT HALL
This special concert will be the first time the full band have performed Pete Townshend's classic rock opera since 1989...

anna murphy WAS BREAKING NEWS: IRON MAIDEN BOOK OF SOULS UK TOUR DATES RIGHT HERE
"Although we love playing festivals and stadiums, it is terrific to return to the intimacy and atmosphere of arenas..."

anna murphy UK EXCLUSIVE: CELLAR DARLING ARE BORN - EX-ELUVEITIE MEMBERS TAKE THE CHALLENGE - FIRST SONGS HERE, FIRST LIVE SHOW ANNOUNCED
"We have fallen. We have screamed. We have battled. We found strength. We will overcome."

ac dc UK EXCLUSIVE: ANGUS YOUNG CONFIRMS AC/DC WILL CONTINUE WITH AXL AND NEW BASS PLAYER
"Axl and Angus are also rumored to want to record new AC/DC material following Guns N' Roses' 'Not In This Lifetime' world tour..."

lords of the land SCOTLAND'S LORDS OF THE LAND FESTIVAL BILL UNVEILED
Dubbed 'Scotland's biggest festival of filth, loud noise and destruction', the organisers have once again dug deep...

cliff williams CLIFF WILLIAMS PLAYS HIS FINAL GIG WITH AC/DC AND WHO WE THINK COULD REPLACE HIM
"I couldn't have asked for anything more - being with the people I'm with and have been, being in this situation with this band, playing this music."

ultimate jam night NOW WE CAN ALL WATCH ULTIMATE JAM NIGHT DUE TO BROADCAST DEAL WITH ZINNA TV
"Our goal is giving music lovers a chance to experience something fresh on the live music scene."

suicidal tendencies SUICIDAL TENDENCIES NEW ALBUM ‘WORLD GONE MAD’ IS OUT SEPTEMBER 30th
"I think it's very typical and very traditional Suicidal Tendencies. It's that unforgettable style. It's Mike Muir."

gojira GOJIRA DEBUT NEW VIDEO FOR 'THE SHOOTING STAR'
'Magma' took the #1 spot on Billboard’s Hard Rock Albums chart this summer making them the first French band to hold the #1 spot in the chart's nine year existence...

glenn hughes GLENN HUGHES PREMIERES 'HEAVY', FIRST VIDEO FROM 'RESONATE'
'Resonate' is already a contender for Album of the Year and features Glenn's live solo band members...

prophets of rage PROPHETS OF RAGE RELEASE THEIR VERY FIRST VIDEO: 'THE PARTY'S OVER' EP OUT NOW
"An elite task force of revolutionary musicians determined to confront this mountain of election year bullshit..."

iggy pop IGGY POP: 'POST POP DEPRESSION: LIVE AT THE ROYAL ALBERT HALL' ON THE WAY
The Telegraph said: "I have been going to gigs for a very long time and that was one of the best I have ever seen."

hawklords HAWKLORDS UK TOUR DATES ARE HERE: GIRLSCHOOL'S KIM McAULIFFE GUESTS ON NEW ALBUM
"Exploring the themes of sex, death, art, time and identity. It's above and beyond a normal rock album!"

amon amarth AMON AMARTH PREMIERE 'RAISE YOUR HORNS' VIDEO FEATURING MANY SPECIAL GUESTS
Special guests include Biff and Paul from Saxon, Behemoth's Nergal, Rob Flynn of Machine Head, Doro, Jessie Leach, Zakk Wylde and many more...

thunder THUNDER MARCH 2017 UK TOUR DATES ARE HERE
"If we’re not playing the city/town where you live that's because we tried, but it wasn't available in the time frame. We did not do it on purpose."

pythia PYTHIA BASS PLAYER MARK HARRINGTON REPLACED BY ASH PORTER
"No drama, no problems, no fall outs etc, just simply a case that over time people's circumstances and situations can change...

the shockwaves EXCLUSIVE: NYC ROCKERS THE SHOCKWAVES DEBUT NEW SINGLE 'LIES' ON MetalTalk
The Shockwaves spent the summer in the studio hammering out new songs which will be released as a series of singles over the next few months...

skarlett riot SKARLETT RIOT FORCED TO CANCEL LONDON GIG
""Is this good business? Is this how we and the other bands on the bill should be treated and how our fans should be treated?"

def con one DEF CON ONE RELEASE FREE DOWNLOAD OF SEX PISTOLS 'ANARCHY IN THE UK'
"The crowds went absolutely crazy for it and quite a few people have suggested we should record it and release it..."

nightwish NIGHTWISH SINGER FLOOR JANSEN IS FOUR MONTHS PREGNANT
Additionally, today Ghost have released a Deluxe Version of 'Meliora', their acclaimed 2015 Grammy® Award-winning album...

eluveitie WAS BREAKING NEWS: ELUVEITIE CONFIRM NEW ALBUM DETAILS AND NEW ACOUSTIC SHOWS
"We're looking forward to 'Evocation II'! The concept of the album sticks in our head already for years and it has matured a lot..."

ghost GHOST ANNOUNCE SURPRISE NEW EP AND NEW VIDEO, AVAILABLE HERE NOW
Additionally, today Ghost have released a Deluxe Version of 'Meliora', their acclaimed 2015 Grammy® Award-winning album...

status quo BREAKING NEWS: RICK PARFITT DIED FOR SEVERAL MINUTES AND MAY HAVE PERFORMED HIS LAST QUO GIG
"He is far from being fit enough to undertake the rigours of Quo's touring schedule..."

black sabbath BLACK SABBATH TO RELEASE 'THE ULTIMATE COLLECTION': RE-MASTERED SET AVAILABLE NEXT MONTH WITH CRUCIFOLD VINYL TO FOLLOW
Curated in conjunction with the band, the 31-track offering features many classic songs..

the answer THE ANSWER REVEAL NEW SINGLE AND TITLE TRACK FROM FORTHCOMING ALBUM
The album is a hugely varied body of work encompassing elements of their Celtic background as well as their renowned trademark guitar attack...

sonic syndicate SONIC SYNDICATE ARE REBORN: NEW ALBUM 'CONFESSIONS' ON THE WAY
Aware that the band's 'new start' may cause a lot of listeners to raise their eyebrows the band do not fear the changes nor the future...

john otway OTWAY GOES WHERE NO BAND HAS BEEN IN OVER QUARTER OF A CENTURY
He's the first artist to record on the Caribbean island since The Rolling Stones made 'Steel Wheels' there in 1989...

out came the wolves OUT CAME THE WOLVES REVEAL DETAILS OF DEBUT ALBUM 'STRANGE FATE'
"This album is the culmination of our endless hard work and we couldn't be more excited to finally reach this turning point..."

kiss EXCLUSIVE KISS 'GODS OF THUNDER' DOCUMENTARY SET FOR 2017 RELEASE
As well as unseen footage of the band, the documentary was said to feature new interviews...

korn KORN AND LIMP BIZKIT ANNOUNCE UK TOUR FOR DECEMBER
Korn are return to the UK in December for an arena tour in support of their hotly anticipated, twelfth studio album...

santana SANTANA IV: 'LIVE AT THE HOUSE OF BLUES, LAS VEGAS' ON THE WAY
This release captures the long anticipated reunion of the classic and much-heralded line-up of Santana...

second relation EXCLUSIVE SECOND RELATION DEBUT VIDEO FOR 'COUNTLESS DAMAGES' ON MetalTalk
"The motion picture for the second single ‘Countless Damages’ is a schematic translation of the lyrics..."

queen UK EXCLUSIVE QUEEN + ADAM LAMBERT BRING A KIND OF MAGIC TO ISRAEL
Brian May and Roger Taylor each sang a song in Freddie's memory, and concert clips featuring the legendary frontman were prominent throughout...

phil campbell PHIL CAMPBELL AND THE BASTARD SONS TO RELEASE DEBUT EP ON MOTÖRHEAD MUSIC
Phil Campbell And The Bastard Sons are about to fly a mighty Welsh rock'n'roll flag in your direction...

veil of delusions VEIL OF DELUSIONS ANNOUNCE UK DATES
The band have played numerous shows across Europe, including appearances at the Amsterdam Metalfest 2016 and the FemMe Battle...

leonard haze LEONARD HAZE, FORMER Y&T DRUMMER, PASSES AWAY
"Kelly said that although his health had recently declined, they felt he had a few years left, so this is unexpected..."

scorpions SCORPIONS APPOINT MOTÖRHEAD DRUMMER MIKKEY DEE AS PERMANENT MEMBER
"The Scorpions fans have been most welcoming and its been great to meet all the crazy wonderful Motörheadbangers along the way..."

avenged sevenfold AVENGED SEVENFOLD ADD A SECOND NIGHT AT LONDON’S O2 ARENA
Tickets for all dates of what will be the band's first UK tour for three years are on sale here...

vixen VIXEN ANNOUNCED FOR HARD ROCK HELL AND BERNIE MARSDEN IS READY AND WILLING TOO
"Vixen will be a class addition - they are on fire at the moment, so it's a nice wee exclusive to add to the line-up..."

deep purple RITCHIE BLACKMORE: IAN GILLAN IS SICK AND DEEP PURPLE SHOULD GIVE IT A REST
"I'm deteriorating very fast, as we all are. All my friends are passing away. Some of my enemies are passing away too..."

europe EUROPE ANNOUNCE TAX THE HEAT, DARE AND THE ELECTRIC BOYS AS THE FINAL COUNTDOWN 30th ANNIVERSARY TOUR SUPPORT
"They are one of the young new bands out there that are keeping the rock business exciting and vibrant..."

napalm death NAPALM DEATH ANNOUNCE 2017 IRISH DATES
Napalm Death’s acclaimed fifteenth album release 'Apex Predator - Easy Meat' managed to enter the sales charts in several countries across the world upon release...

neal morse band THE NEAL MORSE BAND NEW ALBUM OUT 11th NOVEMBER: WORLDWIDE TOUR DATES ARE HERE
"Someone had suggested to me that I do a concept album based on this book, but I kind of forgot about it. Then when I began writing new songs last December..."

glenn hughes GLENN HUGHES NEW STUDIO ALBUM IS ABOUT TO 'RESONATE': UK AND EUROPEAN TOUR DATES ARE HERE
Now, finally, his first solo album in over eight years will see the light of day...

judas priest EXCLUSIVE JUDAS PRIEST HELL BENT FOR BLOODSTOCK 2017?
When this will be officially announced is anyone's guess but what we do know is that festival organisers are working hard right now to secure next year's headliners...

the skids THE SKIDS HEAD BACK INTO THE VALLEY WITH 2017 40th ANNIVERSARY TOUR
One of the gigs on the 40th anniversary tour will be a hometown performance at Dunfermline's Glen Pavilion...

possessed POSSESSED ANNOUNCE GLASGOW/LONDON DATES
The current line-up have been working together since 2013 and despite playing festival shows in Europe in 2014, this tour includes their first ever Scottish live date...

slayer SLAYER: AND THEN THERE WERE THREE...
"Slayer is notorious for letting the artist be the artist, the producer be the producer, and the director be the director, etc..."

metal talk
© All written site content is copyright MetalTalk.net 2008-2016, unless otherwise stated, and is not to be used without prior permission.
Ads raid data recovery