metal talk
facebook
Type band name, album name, artists name etc here...
Search all our articles by typing band name, album name, artists name etc here...
news now
metal talk




  JONATHAN CHURCHILL: DEFENDING OUR ISLAND

LOU REED & METALLICA
'Lulu'
(Warner Bros)
Released: 31st October 2011


jonathan churchill

Pin It
Share |


You know the dread that comes over you when a friend offers to show you all their wedding photos? And the video too? Well that's the feeling you ought to get if somebody offers to play you a track from Lou Reed and Metallica's collaboration, 'Lulu'. I've had the opportunity to listen to the entire album. All of it. Every note. It's fair to say that it has left a lasting impression.

metallicaloureedlulu

MetalTalk.net is all about positivity. We love our Metal and we're certainly not here to knock rock stars with fragile egos and too much money off their perches. Something, however, has gone horribly wrong and it's only fair that we should hold a Metal inquisition.

The first thing to establish is exactly what on earth this is. Well, according to the official press release, 'Lulu' is a set of extended songs inspired by German expressionist Frank Wedekind's early 20th Century plays, 'Earth Spirit' and 'Pandora's Box' (much admired by Freud). The plays, originally published in 1904 and set in Germany, Paris and London in the 1890s, whirl between the points of view of Lulu, an inverted-Eve-like cipher-mirror of desire and abuse, and the people who fall desperately in love with her. Then she meets Jack The Ripper...

Article continues below...

   


Reed had previously sketched out some lyrics and after meeting with Metallica in 2009, they decided to work together. At first glance, a genuinely innovative and exciting idea. The power and intensity of Metallica in full flow, but with a lyricist and poet who can write words that infiltrate your soul.

As a fully inducted member of the Rock 'n' Roll Hall of Fame, Lou Reed has earned a great deal of respect throughout his career. His dark, obscure and nihilistic outpourings are perfect for heavy Metal and there's a genuine resonance between the music and lyrics on Lulu. It's unfortunate then that, as far as I can tell, it's pure self-indulgent nonsense.

What we have here is a mixed bag of pretentious lyrics and tedious music which surprises and delights in equal measure. Surprises because it's much more boring and faux-intellectual than I could have imagined. And delights because it is hilarious to think that thousands of unsuspecting rednecks in the Deep South may be getting this for Christmas alongside their new baseball cap and Kid Rock's Greatest Hits.

In my opinion, Metallica have struggled for years now to lay the ghost of 'The Black Album' to rest. Regardless of your opinion on thatrecord, it is a monster and it's not that they aren't talented enough to move forward, but I've always felt they lost their sense of purpose. As a fervently anti-establishment band in the early eighties, 'The Black Album' introduced them to the mainstream. It simultaneously launched them into the stratosphere and ruined their Metal credentials. Millions of people who would never touch a Slayer or Megadeth album suddenly embraced Metallica, who just recently performed at a corporate event for Salesforce.com. That's the sort of behaviour you expect from KISS, not a proper thrash Metal band.

Lou Reed, on the other hand, clearly needs an outlet for his poetry. The bin would be my suggestion. However, Metallica have decided to put it to music. Fair enough. They probably weren't sure how to politely say "no", and the next thing you know they're all in a recording studio, and one thing led to another. I'm presuming Trent Reznor had a similar issues when Rob Halford popped in one day wearing a feather boa and eyeliner, clutching some surreal lyrics, asking to make an industrial album with his new band, 2wo.

What interests me is that the album is very true to itself and is totally non-commercial. It means that if this sells or is critically acclaimed, it will be on the strength of the material and not because there are two famous names involved. The cover artwork is provocative and blatantly sets the tone for what's inside. And the overall lyrical content and musical feel is basically the mad Danish director, Lars von Trier, set to music. So far so Lou Reed then.

Getting under the skin of 'Lulu' requires patience, stamina and a very open mind. It's a record that will polarise opinion for years to come, but I'm sure - just like Meatloaf's 'Bat Out Of Hell III' - there is somebody, somewhere, alone and in a black T-shirt, who will genuinely appreciate this record.

Notable moments include:

'The View', an interesting slow-paced track with a gentle drum intro and an introspective poetry-style spoken word delivery. There's a real sense of Michael Stipe's vocal from REM's 'New Adventures In Hi-Fi', another deliberately non-commercial piece. This track reminds me strongly of 'E-bow The Letter'. It's just nowhere near as good.

'Frustration' focuses just on the drums and vocals for large parts. It's interesting to hear Lars freestyling with Reed droning over the top. It's certainly different and definitely doesn't sound like it was written by an eight year-old with ADHD.

According to press interviews with the band, 'Junior Dad', the nineteen-minute finale, brought James and Kirk to tears. The last eight minutes or so is just the sound of what may be a viola gently playing one note. It will reduce most Metallica fans to tears.

anthraxworshipmusic

Conclusion:

Reviewing a collaboration is a tricky business. Is this a Metallica album featuring Lou Reed or a Lou Reed album featuring Metallica? The difference is important. Lou Reed being a seminal sixties and seventies artistic pioneer. Metallica being the world's most popular heavy Metal band. They have widely different audiences and little crossover.

A new Lou Reed album is to be treated with extreme caution. It's bound to be 'artistic' and 'challenging' and have an alleged intellectual depth. Invariably, it won't be popular.

These days though, a new Metallica album is, in fact, also to be treated with caution! Recent releases have been - um - 'artistic', 'challenging' and have had an alleged new-found intellectual depth. Invariably, they aren't popular.

Having put 'Lulu' through a Metal Inquisition and tightened the thumbscrews on this bizarre experiment, it's fair to say that I think this is very much a Lou Reed record. Metallica have done a fair job of creating an audio landscape for his poetic gushing, but the lyrics and delivery by Reed is so dominant that it's easy to overlook Metallica's contribution. As such, if you're a fan of Lou Reed, this is another great challenging artistic piece with hidden depths. I'm sure it will win a Grammy or find favour with pseudo-intellectuals who enjoy alternative sounds.

If you're Metallica fan, I'd suggest you don't put yourself through the torment of this record. There's little here for thrash fans and it's best viewed as an experiment and not a proper Metallica record. For those brave enough to take the 'Lulu' challenge - please post your comments below or on the MetalTalk.net Facebook page! For me - it's a thumbs down. It's not an album I'd ever listen to under any circumstances, but credit to Metallica for trying something new. However, Anthrax and Megadeth have both been busy in the studio proving that their 1980s success was no fluke. Megadeth's previous two albums have been outstanding and Anthrax's 'Worship Music' is easily one of the albums of the year. The question must be asked why on earth Metallica aren't able to find a similar vein of form? They certainly seem to have time on their hands to showcase their talents with Lou Reed.

Listen to whole album:

http://www.loureedmetallica.com/listen-to-lulu.php


26.10.11

Jonathan Churchill. MetalTalk.net
Follow me on Twitter: MetalTalk_1976


Share |








 

hawkwind HAWKWIND RELEASE NEW ALBUM 'THE MACHINE STOPS' IN APRIL 2016
A concept studio album and a live stage show, 'The Machine Stops' is based on E.M. Forster's sci-fi classic...

broken witt rebels BROKEN WITT REBELS ANNOUNCE 'GEORGIA PINE' EP FEATURING THE NEW SINGLE 'LOW'
The band will also head out on live UK dates in April and May...

struts THE STRUTS UNVEIL OFFICIAL VIDEO FOR NEW SINGLE 'KISS THIS'
The clip features candid footage highlighting the frenzied response from fans and the band's celebrated and explosive live show...

sabaton SABATON RELEASE THE OFFICIAL LIVE VIDEO FOR 'CAROLUS REX'
Sabaton hit the UK shores in a co-headline tour with Alestorm in February and March...

cairo son CAIRO SON RELEASE NEW SINGLE 'DEVILS TONGUE' ON FEB 22nd
The single is taken from the album 'Storm Clouds', released on March 14th...

rebelles THE REBELLES RELEASE 'ALL THE YOUNG DUDES' SINGLE ON MARCH 18TH FEATURING IAN HUNTER
The track is taken from the forthcoming debut album. "Expect to hear a punk attitude draped in silk with a few sharp edges..."

donovan DONOVAN TO PLAY 70TH BIRTHDAY CONCERT AT LONDON PALLADIUM
The flag bearer for all things psychedelic will celebrate his early bohemian roots...

kiss KISS EUROPEAN TOUR CANCELLED?
German and Italian dates have been removed from the official website...

stone free STONE FREE FESTIVAL ANNOUNCES LATEST LINE-UP ADDITIONS
Additions include Pink Floyd's Wish You Were Here Symphonic Live, Michael Monroe, Jackaman, Therapy, Jared James Nicols and more...

last great dreamers LAST GREAT DREAMERS TO PLAY UK SHOWS IN FEBRUARY
Last Great Dreamers jumped at the chance to take a break from writing their third album to get back on the road for a few dates...

motorhead DOWNLOAD TO RENAME 2016 MAIN STAGE AFTER LEMMY PLUS LOTS MORE MOTÖRHEAD NEWS
Where the band's name previously appeared on the billing, there is now a graphic of Lemmy's hat...

zakk wylde ZAKK WYLDE TO RELEASE 'BOOK OF SHADOWS II' ON APRIL 8 2016
Wylde's first solo release for 20 years will be followed by a wave of tour dates to be announced soon...

status quo STATUS QUO TO RELEASE ANOTHER TRIO OF DELUXE EDITION ALBUMS
These carefully curated special releases are to be issued by Universal Music on Friday 25th March...

hrh doom stoner HRH DOOM vs HRH STONER ANNOUNCE MORE BANDS
Angel Witch, Electric Citizen and Black Spiders head up another batch to be added for this October...

the defiled THE DEFILED ANNOUNCE RESCHEDULED UK HEADLINE TOUR FOR MAY
The Defiled will play as support to In This Moment, also in May...

rich robinson RICH ROBINSON RELEASES REISSUES AND NEW ALBUM
The four re-imagined albums include previously unreleased tracks and penned essays from Robinson himself...

crowbar CROWBAR ANNOUNCE EUROPEAN TOUR DATES
The run of twenty dates includes a UK appearance at Desertfest...

ben poole BEN POOLE CONFIRMS NEW ALBUM 'TIME HAS COME' AND UK TOUR
"I hope it'll please the blues-rock guitar fans, but also have the depth and maturity to appeal to an audience beyond that..."

desertfest DESERTFEST BERLIN 2016'S LINE-UP IS ALMOST COMPLETE
The first running order has been released, along with a limited number of day passes...

anneke van giersbergen DUTCH LEGEND ANNEKE VAN GIERSBERGEN BRINGS HER ACOUSTIC SHOW TO THE UK
Six solo dates in April have been arranged before Anneke returns to the studio...

hard rock hell HARD ROCK HELL X ANNOUNCE FIRST 15 BANDS
Ugly Kid Joe, Ratt, Glenn Hughes and Living Colour head the vanguard for this year's 10th anniversary...

space elevator SPACE ELEVATOR LAUNCH PLEDGE CAMPAIGN FOR SECOND ALBUM
There are a number of exclusive offers for Pledgers, including the chance to perform on the album...

valerian VALERIAN TO RELEASE 'STARDUST REVELATION' ALBUM
With a burgeoning Metal scene in Indonesia, the band have been working hard on their first full length album...

terry horbury vardis A MEMORIAL CONCERT AND BIRTHDAY PARTY FOR TERRY HORBURY OF VARDIS WILL TAKE PLACE ON 6TH FEBRUARY 2016
The unmissable event features a host of very special guests and all proceeds will go to Terry's chosen charity...

status quo STATUS QUO ANNOUNCE THE END OF ELECTRIC SHOWS
"There's more to come from us in the years ahead, but we won't tour the electric set ever again..."

toseland TOSELAND ANNOUNCE NEW ALBUM 'CRADLE THE RAGE' & MARCH TOUR
Support for the ten date UK tour comes from Colour Of Noise...

bonfire BONFIRE CELEBRATE 30TH ANNIVERSARY WITH NEW DOUBLE ALBUM 'PEARLS'
The classics are being re-recorded in Italy, with completely new arrangements...

hostile HOSTILE ANNOUNCE NEW ALBUM PRODUCED BY KK DOWNING PLUS EUROPEAN TOUR DATES
'The New World Disorder' is set for release via Gasworks Music and will be available on March 1st 2016...

rambliin man GINGER BAKER'S AIRFORCE 3, SEBASTIAN BACH AND THE CADILLAC THREE AMONG THE LATEST BATCH OF NAMES TO BE ANNOUNCED FOR RAMBLIN' MAN FAIR
Purson, Inglorious and The Zombies will also join the Kent festival this coming July...

the enid THE ENID RELEASE DUST ON 1ST APRIL
'Dust' is the final part of the stunning trilogy following 'Journey's End' and 'Invicta' and will be performed around the UK over the coming months...

sanguine EXCLUSIVE: SANGUINE PREMIERE VIDEO FOR 'SAVE ME' PRIOR TO RELEASE OF SECOND ALBUM 'BLACK SHEEP'
The sci-fi spectacular is directed by Tyson Wade Johnston and its premiere can be seen exclusively on MetalTalk right here...

steelhouse festival STEELHOUSE FESTIVAL ANNOUNCES MORE BANDS
Hey! Hello! featuring Ginger Wildheart, Blues Pills and Vega have been added to the line-up of this year's Steelhouse Festival in Hafod-y-Dafal in Wales...

jeff healey PROVOGUE RELEASE LOST JEFF HEALEY ALBUM TO COMMEMORATE HIS 50TH BIRTHDAY
These tracks were painstakingly restored and brought to life bringing into focus Jeff's unique and special gifts as an artist...

heretic order THE HERETIC ORDER UNLEASH VIDEO FOR 'THE DEATH RIDE BLUES'
The Heretic Order have announced a co-headlining UK tour in February with I.C.O.N...

mortiis MORTIIS ANNOUNCE UK HEADLINE TOUR
"It's about time we came back to the UK for some shows. See you in May, you bastards..."

zoax ZOAX ANNOUNCE SPECIAL ONE OFF LONDON SHOW
Catch Zoax in Camden on February 23rd where they will premiere some new songs...

antimatter ANTIMATTER ANNOUNCE RARE UK DATES
Antimatter will play two further dates on 'The Judas Tour' in Bristol and Manchester in March...

jimmy bain JIMMY BAIN PASSES AWAY AGED 68
Ex-Dio and Rainbow and current Last In Line bass player Jimmy Bain has sadly passed away aged 68...

rhapsody of fire RHAPSODY OF FIRE WILL COME TO INDONESIA FOR THE FIRST TIME
On the 'In To The Legend Asian Tour 2016', Rhapsody of Fire will stop in Jakarta on March 8th 2016...

steven tyler AEROSMITH'S STEVEN TYLER ANNOUNCES NEW SINGLE 'RED, WHITE & YOU'
Steven Tyler continues his foray into country music and reveals his latest track...

the treatment THE TREATMENT ANNOUNCE APRIL /MAY UK TOUR
The Amorettes will be special guests on all fourteen UK dates...

soto SOTO TO RELEASE SECOND ALBUM ON 1ST APRIL 2016
Soto will debut live during Feb 2016 with a string of East Coast US dates and a European debut in April with a short run through selected cities and countries...

temperance movement HEAR THE TEMPERANCE MOVEMENT LIVE AND ACOUSTIC AT DEEZER, PARIS
The band dropped into Deezer headquarters during a stop on their current tour promoting new album 'White Bear'...

jezabels CANCER TREATMENT FORCES THE JEZABELS TO CANCEL WORLD TOUR
"The band means so much to me, and cancelling the tour has been a very sad decision. I am hopeful that in the near future we will be back on the road again playing music we love..."

thunder THUNDER ANNOUNCE INTIMATE SHOW AT LONDON'S 100 CLUB
All ticket-sale profits will be going to Childline/NSPCC. Tickets for the special one-off show go on sale on 22nd January...

freddy lim HEAVY METAL STAR ELECTED TO PARLIAMENT IN HISTORIC VICTORY
Freddy Lim, the long-haired, tattooed front man of Taiwanese Black Metal band Chthonic wins a seat in parliament...

hrh doom stoner HRH ANNOUNCE NEW DOOM & STONER SHEFFIELD TRIP
Candlemass, Orange Goblin, Torche and Raging Speedhorn lead the vanguard for HRH's new event...

the mission THE MISSION ANNOUNCE 30TH ANNIVERSARY TOUR
The tour starts in Dublin on October 1st and includes O2 Shepherds Bush Empire in London on October 8th...

cop uk NEW ALBUM FROM C.O.P. UK 'NO PLACE FOR HEAVEN' IS OUT ON 29TH JANUARY
C.O.P. UK will immediately follow the release by hitting the road for a European tour with Helloween...

thin lizzy THIN LIZZY ANNOUNCE 2016 ANNIVERSARY SHOWS: MOTÖRHEAD DRUMMER MIKKEY DEE JOINS BAND
2016 is a year that includes a couple of important anniversaries in the history of Thin Lizzy...

joe bonamassa JOE BONAMASSA RELEASES NEW ALBUM 'BLUES OF DESPERATION' IN MARCH 2016
"You'll hear the proverbial trains, mountains, valleys and other blues references about heartbreak and loneliness, but there are also some poignant moments..."

cairo son CAIRO SON 'STORM CLOUDS' ALBUM LAUNCH SHOW CONFIRMED
The launch party will be held at Nambucca on March 18th...

stormbringer STORMBRINGER ADD NEW DATES TO FEBRUARY SHOWS SUPPORTING THEIR NEW ALBUM 'BLOOD AND RUST'
Check out the dates plus the videos for 'Bad Blood' and 'Rust' right here...

sanguine SANGUINE UNLEASH THEIR VEGAS SPECTACULAR WITH NEW VIDEO FOR 'PRETTY GIRL'
"The lyrics reflect my frustration that women are not meant to be both pretty and strong...but it's more of a 'fuck you' than a complaint..."

glenn frey GLENN FREY OF THE EAGLES PASSES AWAY AGED 67
Glenn Frey, the founder member and guitarist of The Eagles has sadly checked out...

dale griffin MOTT THE HOOPLE DRUMMER DALE GRIFFIN PASSES AWAY AGED 67
Dale "Buffin" Griffin was a founder member of Mott The Hoople and prolific session producer...

stiff little fingers STIFF LITTLE FINGERS ANNOUNCE UK TOUR DATES FOR FEBRUARY/MARCH 2016
Support will come from Ricky Warwick & The Fighting Hearts ...

inglorious INGLORIOUS CONFIRMED FOR SWEDEN'S STOCKHOLM ROCKS FESTIVAL 2016
Inglorious and Grand Magus are the first bands to be announced for 2016...

wishing well WISHING WELL FEATURING GRAHAM BONNET RELEASE 'HIPPIE HEART GYPSY SOUL'
"We wanted something extra to boost the album and when we wrote 'Hippie' we instantly realized that Graham would be a perfect vocalist for the song in many ways..."

sabaton SABATON REVEAL THE OFFICIAL LIVE VIDEO FOR 'RESIST AND BITE' TAKEN FROM FORTHCOMING LIVE RELEASE
"We recorded two shows in case one is not enough for you..."

babymetal BABYMETAL ANNOUNCE NEW ALBUM TITLE
'Metal Resistance' is released worldwide on April 1st before their headline Wembley show the next day...

motorhead MOTÖRHEAD: THE TRAIN KEEPS A-ROLLIN'
We hope to see Phil and Mikkey back in full-time action as soon as possible, as well as Fast Eddie...

evil scarecrow EVIL SCARECROW RELEASE THEIR BRILLIANTLY BONKERS LYRIC VIDEO FOR 'END LEVEL BOSS'
The fan favourite will finally appear in the live show for the remaining shows of the 'Boldly Going Anywhere!' tour...

life of agony LIFE OF AGONY SIGN WORLDWIDE DEAL WITH NAPALM RECORDS
'A Place Where There's No More Pain' will be released later in 2016...

metal church METAL CHURCH ANNOUNCE TRACK LISTING AND COVER ARTWORK FOR NEW ALBUM 'XI'
The band's 11th studio release marks the return of legendary vocalist and front man Mike Howe...

twisted sister NEW EUROPEAN RELEASE DATE AND NEW COVER ARTWORK REVEALED FOR THE MOVIE 'WE ARE TWISTED F*CKING SISTER!'
The documentary is a mesmerizing and wickedly funny story of a 10 year odyssey to overnight success...

saxon SAXON TO RELEASE 9 ALBUM VINYL BOX SET
This spectacular package is a must have for Saxon fans and collectors and will be released in March...

wildfire festival WILDFIRE FESTIVAL 2016 ANNOUNCE DAY SPLITS
Saturday night headliners, running order and set times for Scotland's premier rock and Metal festival will be announced in February...

black stone cherry BLACK STONE CHERRY TO PLAY CHARITY GIG AT THE BORDERLINE ON JANUARY 24th
All proceeds of this special appearance will go to The Teenage Cancer Trust...

trivium TRIVIUM ANNOUNCE UK TOUR WITH SOME SURPRISING CHOICES OF VENUE
None of the regular main cities like London, Birmingham, Manchester or Glasgow are included on this jaunt...

yes YES TO TOUR UK AND EUROPE IN APRIL
The set will include 1971's 'Fragile' and 1980's 'Drama' in their entirety...

blind guardian BLIND GUARDIAN ANNOUNCE UK AND IRELAND TOUR IN MAY
Blind Guardian will be playing a spellbinding 150 minute long set every night – these shows are not to be missed...

fish farewell FISH ANNOUNCES APRIL HEADLINE TOUR DUE TO PHENOMENAL DEMAND
Another final chance to see 'Misplaced Childhood' in full following the recent sold out run and including the rescheduled European shows...

morgoth MORGOTH ANNOUNCE EUROPEAN TOUR WITH INCANTATION
Be sure not to miss this killer package of total Death Metal sovereignty...

iron maiden IRON MAIDEN TO TOUR CHINA FOR FIRST TIME IN THEIR CAREER
Iron Maiden will visit China in April 2016, once their set list has been submitted for approval from the Ministry Of Culture...

3 doors down 3 DOORS DOWN ANNOUNCE NEW ALBUM 'US AND THE NIGHT' OUT MARCH 11th
"It's truly been a labour of love and we can't wait to get these songs out to our fans around the world..."

prong PRONG RELEASE NEW ALBUM ON FEBRUARY 5th
'X – No Absolutes' is packed with the band's trademark driving riffs and pinpoint-precise grooves...

skarlett riot SKARLETT RIOT HEAD OUT ON TOUR WITH DEVILSKIN
Skarlett Riot will be main support to Devilskin for six UK dates in February...

metal talk
© All written site content is copyright MetalTalk.net 2008-2015, unless otherwise stated, and is not to be used without prior permission.
Ads raid data recovery